a two-fold critique on milton friedman’s instrumentalist methodology
نویسندگان
چکیده
milton friedman’s seminal article, “methodology of positive economics”, is one of the most important and contentious works ever been discussed within the realm of economic methodology. in this article, on the basis of an instrumentalist approach to the nature of theorizing, friedman declares the tenets of positive economics, and in this vein, he professes his disputable doctrine about “unrealistic assumptions” as the core of his view. in this article, we try to discuss over some logical and theoretical defects in friedman’s article which essentially weakens his supportive arguments about his views (internal critique); furthermore, in the light of lakatos’ epistemological framework, we take into consideration the epistemological status of friedman’s predectivist instrumentalism (external critique) and we reach this conclusion that his approach is degenerating in lakatosian term. jel classification: jel: b41، b49
منابع مشابه
A Critique on Feminist Research Methodology
In almost all advanced countries of the world, the discourse about the existence or other wise of a feminist research methodology has been live at least for the last few decades. There are argument in favour of and against the existence of such a methodology to be called “Feminist” and its validity. This article criticizes the arguments made by feminist research methodology and maintains that t...
متن کاملA Critique of Stochastic Discount Factor Methodology
The stochastic discount factor (SDF) methodology is becoming quite popular in recent empirical asset pricing studies. It appears that this new methodology, as claimed, is going to replace traditional methodologies. In this paper, we point out that, because the current practice of the stochastic discount factor methodology ignores a fully specified model for asset returns, it suffers from two po...
متن کاملParticipatory Research: Methodology and Critique
The epistemology of participatory research relates knowledge to action, especially the production of knowledge and political action to redress inequality .This paper identifies characteristics of participatory research and describes three research efforts which exemplify them in varying degrees. The tenets of participatory research suggest guidelines for degrees, the conduct of inquiry for soci...
متن کاملMilton Friedman’s Stance: The Methodology of Causal Realism
model” simpler than the real world and tied to it through rules for a class of applications and correspondences (p. 24). The parts of a theory are interdeducible, so that what may, from one point of view, be taken to be an axiom may, from another point of view, be taken to be a theorem (pp. 26-27). How to classify various theoretical propositions is mainly a matter of finding the most economica...
متن کاملMilton : a New , Unique
Petrography: The interior of the stone consists of relatively small (mean grain size 1.6 mm), angular olivine grains (~73 vol%) in an iron metal matrix (Fig. 1). Ferric oxides are abundant. Samples easily fragment because of the weathering and numerous, probably preterrestrial, fractures. Olivine contains numerous small (typically 50 μm diameter) inclusions, visible in the SEM, that consist of ...
متن کاملa critique on “the qur’an and pluralism”, part two
in this article the second and the third chapters of the book, “the qur’an and pluralism” is reviewed. according to the writer, there is an inconsistency between religious exclusivism and forbearance and tolerance and it is not possible to both conclude exclusivism from the qur’anic verses and seek to prove tolerance and forbearance. thus, the impressions given by the verses of the first chapte...
متن کاملمنابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
تحقیقات اقتصادیجلد ۴۵، شماره ۴، صفحات ۱۸۱-۲۰۰
کلمات کلیدی
میزبانی شده توسط پلتفرم ابری doprax.com
copyright © 2015-2023